Top 7 Best Bay Rum Aftershave To Avoid Painful Shaving Rash


Bay rum aftershave has become quite popular recently because of its unique aroma and healing properties.

It has a sweet and spicy sensual scent which is too irresistible. The ingredients used in this aftershave have healing properties which treat any cuts and stops bleeding. Apart from that, it also soothes and moisturizes the skin.

Because of its popularity, many brands have developed bay rum aftershave products. To choose the best option among them can be tricky. However, with the below information, you can make the right choice.

1. Type of aftershave

They are available in four different variants including cream, lotion, gels and balms. When it comes to consistency, balms and creams have thick consistency. They are not suitable for acne-prone and oily skin. Lotion and gels are water based and light in consistency. They are not suitable for dry skin and sensitive skin.

2. Ingredients

Check the label before purchasing aftershave. There are usually composed of either natural or synthetic components. A natural composition will always be a better option as they will leave your skin refreshed and nourished without damaging your skin. Avoid products with harmful ingredients as they dry up your skin and cause irritation.

For more information, refer to our “Buying Guide” which contains all the information necessary to make the right choice. Using the same information, we have shortlisted some of the best bay rum aftershave products approved by dermatologists.

Best Rated Bay Rum Aftershave

Bay AftershaveQuantityIngredientsType of AftershaveBuy Now
Barberry Coast Shave Co.Sale Bay Rum4 Ozcinnamon, cloves, allspice, orange, vanilla and purified water, glycerinSplashCHECK ON AMAZON
Clubman Pinaud Bay Rum12 OzSD 40 Alcohol, water,
clove and cinnamon fragrance
Captain's Bay Rum4.0 Ozalcohol, witch hazel, rum, essential oils and extracts, glycerin.SplashCHECK ON AMAZON
GABELS Bay Rum16 OzSD Alcohol 40, Water, Sucrose Octacetate, Bay Oil, FDandC Yellow No.5LotionCHECK ON AMAZON
Fine Mr Bay Rum Mens Aftershave 3.3 Ozemulsifiers, petroleum, silicone, gluten, phthalates or parabensSplashCHECK ON AMAZON
Ogallala Bay Rum Regular8 Ozbay leaves, cinnamon, cloves, allspice, orange, vanilla and purified waterLotionCHECK ON AMAZON
Suavecito Bay Rum Aftershave4 Oznatural ingredientsBalmCHECK ON AMAZON

Best Rated Bay Rum Aftershave: Reviews

1. Barberry Coast Shave Co.Sale Bay Rum

Barberry Coast Shave Co.Sale Bay Rum

This product is composed of 100% natural ingredients. This indicates no parabens, no sulphates and no toxins. This is what makes this product the best bay rum aftershave. It contains pure vegetable glycerin that moisturizes your skin. The bay oil is derived from authentic bay leaves from Dominica. It also consists of cinnamon, cloves, allspice, orange, vanilla and purified water.

This aftershave solution is aged for a minimum of 30 days. This ensures complete blending of natural oils. It has an amazing scent and a crisp burn that diminishes fast while leaving your skin refreshed, moisturized and smooth.


  • natural ingredients
  • 100% pure glycerine
  • Citrus smell


  • Burning sensation

Buy Now at Amazon 

2. Clubman Pinaud Virgin Island Bay Rum

clubman pinaud bay rum

The smell of this aftershave will surely give you a nostalgic feeling. You can heavenly smell clove and cardamon followed by bay leaves. The main component of this aftershave is SD 40 Alcohol. This is usually used for disinfections caused after shaving. Due to this its burning sensation might be a bit high.


  • Smells for a longer time
  • Affordable
  • Protects from disinfections


  • Alcohol is intense

Buy Now at Amazon 

3. Captain’s Choice Original Bay Rum

Captain Choice Original Bay Rum

Our third product will be loved by those who love the traditional smell of alcohol. Along with this it also has a smell of clove and cinnamon. This gives an intense burn which is usually described as the ‘perfect burn’. This starts lightly and quickly accelerates.

Once you are done with shaving, wet your face and pat dry. Now take the aftershave on your palm, rub it and then apply it. Shake well before use.


  • Witch hazelnut has antibiotic properties
  • Glycerin
  • Long-lasting smell


  • Burning sensation might be too intense

Buy Now at Amazon 

4. GABELS Bay Rum After Shave Lotion

GABELS Bay Rum After Shave Lotion

This is an old school product to finish your shave. It uses original bay rum oil that gives it a distinctive smell. Along with this it also contains SD Alcohol 40, Water, Sucrose Octacetate, FD&C Yellow No.5. Once applied after shaving it makes your skin firm and closes the pores to minimize skin irritation.


  • Smells great
  • Soothes skin aftershave
  • Disinfects


  • SD 40 Alcohol intensifies burning

Buy Now at Amazon 

5. Fine Mr Bay Rum Mens Aftershave

Fine Mr Bay Rum Mens Aftershave Fine Mr Bay Rum Men’s Aftershave is a top-quality product that can enhance your shaving routine. With only four basic ingredients, it delivers maximum sensory and therapeutic benefits. Its authentic Dominican Bay Leaf Oil provides a sophisticated, spicy-clean scent.

Plus, it’s free of harmful chemicals such as artificial colors, emulsifiers, petroleum, silicone, gluten, phthalates, or parabens. This aftershave is perfect for modern men who want the best. To use, apply a liberal amount to shaven areas for a satisfying, therapeutic, and refreshing finish. Trust us, it’s a product that lives up to its hype!


  • Delivers maximum benefits with minimal ingredients.
  • Authentic Dominican Bay Leaf Oil provides a natural, sophisticated scent.
  • Free of harmful chemicals.
  • Easy to use.


  • Spicy-clean scent may not appeal to everyone.
  • May not be suitable for sensitive skin.
  • Higher price point.

Buy Now at Amazon 

6. Ogallala Bay Rum Regular

Ogallala Bay Rum

This aftershave has the most long-lasting smell as compared to other products. This is also composed of all-natural ingredients which include witch hazel(moisturizes skin), bay oil, cinnamon, oil of clove bud, rosemary, orange, lime, ginger, sage and wintergreen. These essential oils combine to give an aromatic fragrance. Cobalt blue bottle protects it from harmful sunlight.


  • Natural ingredients
  • Bluebottle to protect from sunlight


  • No glycerin

Buy Now at Amazon 

7. Suavecito Bay Rum Aftershave

Suavecito Bay Rum AftershaveIf you are looking to try something new and rejoice in your personal care, then the Suavecito brand is for you. This bay rum aftershave gives you relaxation with its formula as well as scent.

This 4 Oz aftershave has subtle healing properties along with arresting barbershop-Esque aroma. It effectively heals irritation, redness, or bumps by smoothly closing the open pores on your face. With just one splash, this aftershave with its natural ingredients gives you a smooth and attractive face.


  • Natural ingredients
  • Captivating fragrance
  • Quick and effective healing


  • Too mild

Buy Now at Amazon 

How to Choose a Bay Rum Aftershave?

You have to consider several factors before purchasing a bay rum aftershave. They help you make the right choice based on your requirements and budget.

1. Types of Aftershave

The aftershave products on available in four different categories that include creams, lotions, gels and aftershave balms. Some of them are known for their antiseptic properties while some of them can heal dry and irritated skin.

When it comes to consistency, balms and creams have thick consistency. They are not suitable for acne-prone and oily skin. Lotion and gels are water based and light in consistency. They are not suitable for dry skin and sensitive skin.

  • Normal skin: You might want to stick to splashes. You have the most flexible skin type and you can also try lotions and balms. Just try avoiding alcohol-based aftershaves. Witch hazel and aloe vera would be a good start.
  • Dry skin: Balm would be best suited for you. They don’t contain alcohol and are great at moisturizing.
  • Sensitive skin: It would be better if you use unscented products. Or choose a product that uses only natural ingredient for its aroma.
  • Oily skin: People with oily skin can go for splashes. A moisturizer after using a splash would be recommended.

 You can make the choice based on your preference and requirements.

2. Check the Ingredients

A good aftershave should soothe and refresh your skin while maintaining clean and healthy skin.

  • Check the product labels carefully. An aftershave with all natural ingredients is always better than the synthetic ones.
  • Natural ingredients in the aftershave work in the harmony with your body and help nourish your skin. Whereas a synthetic aftershave can cause irritation or at times allergic reaction.
  • Look for aftershave that contains glycerine, this will prevent your skin from getting dry. A good aftershave should penetrate your skin without leaving any oily residue.

3. Natural or Chemical Ingredients

It is always better to invest in a product that has all natural ingredients. Having few mild chemicals may not be dangerous. However, we recommend to stay away from products that have harmful chemicals as they tend dry your skin. This is more important for people with sensitive skin. Make sure the product you choose doesn’t contain paraben any other aggressive chemicals.

4. The Fragrance

Bay run aftershave is usually present in either woodsy or spicy fragrance. Some of them even come with a strong earthy aroma. When it comes to intensity, they are available in two variants – one that hits the nose and another that has pleasant smell. You can choose anyone based on your preference.

5. Price

You can guess the kind of ingredients used depending on the price of a product. It is obvious that good quality products will use high-quality products.

But you should also consider the amount you are getting for a specific price. Carefully check and compare aftershave before you invest in them.

Difference Between After-Shave Bay Rum Lotion Vs Regular Post-Shave Lotion

Well, both these products have the same purpose. However, the main difference among them is the ingredients present in them.

When it comes to bay rum lotion, they contain two ingredients – rum and bay leaf. Regular aftershave lotion comes with several chemicals which are categorized into alcohol-based and water-based.

Another difference among them is the smell. The bay rum aftershave lotion has a sweet and spicy aroma.

Why Should You Choose a Bay Rum Aftershave?

The main reason for using an aftershave lotion is to soothe the skin, especially who experience skin irritation, rashes, cutting the skin or other similar issues after shaving.

The recipe of bay rum aftershave comes with several healing properties. For instance, most of them have astringent which prevents bleeding from cuts. Some of the ingredients soothe, soften and moisture the skin.

Some people experience bouts after shaving so aftershave lotion can be beneficial in dealing with acne. Apart from that, it is also known to tighten the skin.

Benefits of Bay Rum Aftershave

  • A good aftershave should moisturize your skin. If it contains glycerine, it as an added benefit.
  • Though the primary reason for using aftershave is to avoid skin infections. But it also prevents your skin from drying.
  • While its intense aroma gives you a freshness for a longer period of time.
  • It also promotes hair growth and prevents dandruff.
  • Soothes skin
  • Helps with irritation, rashes and other aftershave problems
  • It has excellent healing properties
  • Helps to prevent acne

Frequently Asked Questions:

1. What does bay rum aftershave smell like?

Ans: It has a light flavour of Jamaican rum, exotic Caribbean spices and west Indies Bay leaf. It has a combination of sweet and spicy aroma but isn’t over-powering.

2. Can I use aftershave as a cologne?

Ans: Yes, you can. Both these products are fundamentally same. The only difference is present in the smell. As aftershave is not as strong as perfume, it will not last long. The cologne has strong smell, which so it will stay for a while and also smells exactly as it was.

3. Which is better to use alcoholic or non-alcoholic aftershave?

Ans: It is better to use non-alcoholic aftershave. The presence of alcohol means it dries out skin and hurts the skin. Though non-alcoholic products might be costlier but will protect your skin from drying out.

4. How to use aftershave?

Ans: Aftershave may be used after shaving or before bedtime. Take a small amount in your palm, rub it and apply on your face.

5. Which is better balm or lotion?

Ans: This can depend on your skin type. If you have an oily texture, try avoiding balm as it can cause pimples or acne. Due to their high moisture content. A splash would be better to use.

While a balm can be used for dry skin. It has high in moisturizing and will prevent your skin from further drying.

6. Is Bay Rum Aftershave good for skin?

Ans: Yes, bay leaves de-stresses your skin, preventing the occurrence of wrinkles and skin breakouts. It also has anti-fungal and anti-bacterial properties.


Now that you know an aftershave is an essential part of your daily grooming. I am sure after going through its advantages and all its key factors, you can definitely choose the right product for you. But let us help you a bit further. Let us suggest you the best among the best. That would be Barberry Coast Shave Co.Sale Bay Rum. The best about this product is, it is made of all-natural ingredients. This indicates this particular aftershave is paraben-free, toxic-free and completely safe for skin. It has an amazing scent that will keep you fresh for a longer period of time.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here